Wednesday, August 22, 2007

The Hidden Half: Images of Women in Middle Eastern Cinema

What are women’s lives like in other parts of the world? This question can be answered in three primary ways: through travel and personal experience, through the news media, and through literature and cinema. At Toronto (2006), Sundance, and the San Francisco International Film Festival this year, a spate of excellent Middle Eastern documentary and narrative films shed light on the subject; and all but one of them was directed by a woman. Bay Area audiences have additional opportunities to catch Middle Eastern films about women at the upcoming Arab Film Festival (October 18–November 4,, the Global Lens film series (November t.b.a.,, and the United Nations Association Film Festival (October 24–28,

Rise Up, Spiral Down ...

In "Offside," Jafar Panahi, the director of well-known Iranian films such as "The Mirror," "The Circle," and "The White Balloon" (all of which tell stories about women and girls), follows a group of young women as they wrestle, deceive, and otherwise attempt to finagle their way into a soccer finals match in Tehran. Iranian law bars women from attending sporting events. During my interview with Mr. Panahi in Toronto, he mentioned that the inspiration for the film arose out of his own 15-year-old daughter’s attempt to sneak into a match wearing a male friend’s robe (she was caught and tossed out). When I asked if he thought the law might change, he replied, “In Islam, women are forbidden to look at men’s bare legs. There is nothing we can do about the religious laws because they are etched in stone, so we can forget about changing the laws.”

"Women’s Prison," directed by Manijeh Hekmat unfolds in a setting more sinister than a sporting arena. Banned in Iran, the film traces the story of women in Iranian society since the Islamic Revolution, through the ordeal of women behind bars. This fascinating drama offered by Global Lens, hinges on the struggle between an independent reform-driven prisoner and a determined warden, compelled by her Islamic beliefs.

"Mainline," by Iranian director Rakhsan Bani-Etemad (co-directed by Mohsen Abdolvahab), dramatizes a young middle-class woman’s downward spiral into heroin addiction. According to the directors, young people under the age of 30 comprise 70 percent of Iran’s population, and drug addiction among this demographic is rising to alarming heights. The filmmakers effectively use a cinema vérité approach to capture the grit and desolation of drug life and the desperate challenges of rehabilitation.

"These Girls," directed by Tahani Rached, plunges deep into Egyptian street life. The documentary follows a group of adolescents who live, suffer, rejoice, and sometimes die, on the streets of Cairo as they sniff glue, prostitute themselves, and band together to create some semblance of security and family. Rached’s empathic connection to “these girls” creates a compassionate film that leaves a lasting impression on the viewer.

Dark though these films are, they signal a new era in the complexity of representations of women in Middle Eastern cinema, and at the forefront of the group is a new work by filmmaker Niki Karimi.

Mapping the New Interior ...

"A Few Days Later…," directed by and starring the well-known Iranian actress and director Karimi ("One Night," "Two Women," "The Hidden Half"), is a minimalist portrait of an educated, professional woman dealing with pressures in all aspects of her life. Shahrzad, a graphic designer, artist, and university professor living in Tehran, is besieged by a demanding boss, a disapproving mother and friends, an obnoxious neighbor, and an indecisive lover.

When I interviewed Karimi at Toronto, I noted that her film—with its melancholic atmosphere, gorgeous landscapes, and a main character who drives (sometimes aimlessly) as she pursues an existential questioning of life––approximates a feminist version of Abbas Kiarostami’s "Taste of Cherry" (1997). “Really!” she laughed, pleased at the comparison. Karimi has, in fact, worked as Kiarostami’s assistant, and he produced her first directing effort "To Have Or Not to Have" (2001). I asked what her impetus was for making her latest film and she suggested, “The film is about things that are happening in society to women my age. I felt that there were few films about the experiences of women. I call this ‘personal cinema,’ not cinema from the commercial film industry. I wanted to show a woman trying to earn money, be on her own, and how many problems can surround her. I wanted to show the distance that she has from society. Because of that, she’s living out of the city. And each day she travels on the road and looks at the city and asks herself, ‘What is this place I’m going to?’”

I mention that Shahrzad appears to lead a very privileged life in comparison to other representations of Iranian women that I have seen on film. While the character may be privileged, Karimi points out, “She is not ‘upper class.’ I mean, she is middle-class: she is working, she is an artist, she is also a professor at a university. She is not very rich, but she is taking care of herself. She is typical of Iranian women. We have so many women lawyers, artists, professors, especially in the last 20 years, we have so many women who have graduated from university. They work, have houses, marry, and divorce, like women in the West.”

The Political is Personal ...

Many of the films I saw this year are suffused in political upheaval, whether it is an undercurrent or the main issue. Malalai Joya, subject of Danish filmmaker Eva Mulvad’s documentary "Enemies of Happiness," is dedicated to improving the lives of her countrywomen. The film follows Joya, a 28-year-old delegate in the Afghanistan parliament, as she campaigns for election, receives threats on her life (there have been four), and subsequently leads a political life where she must remain in hiding or be protected by armed guards in public. "Enemies of Happiness" provides a unique insight into today’s Afghanistan, a society destroyed by war and still ruled by tradition. Joya is a controversial leader for a people who have been promised peace and prosperity, but who continue to be ravaged by war. She successfully negotiates with clan leaders and opium kings, and on behalf of despairing adolescent girls, promised in marriage to men old enough to be their grandfathers. This radical freedom fighter for women displays courage and fosters the belief that one person does make a difference.

The Arab Film Festival recently screened two documentaries about Iraqi women and life in Baghdad during the U.S. occupation. In "The Tenth Planet: A Single Life in Baghdad," by Melis Birder, a young Baghdadi woman describes herself thus: “There are nine planets in the universe and I am the tenth one.” Her name means “planet” in Arabic and she is indeed a world unto herself, unafraid to speak her mind about sex, love and politics. "Baghdad Days" is by and about Heba Bassem, a young student from Kirkuk, who returns to Baghdad after the war to finish her film studies at the Art Academy. For her final project, Heba captures her struggles to complete her studies in the semi-destroyed city of Baghdad, where nothing remains the same.

One film, from Global Lens, offers a stunning look at two women’s experiences in Algeria. "Enough!," by Djamila Sahraoui, takes place in the 1990s, and follows a nurse and a doctor; the husband of the latter has been abducted by rebel forces unhappy with his reportage. The women, anachronisms in Islamist Algeria, reflect on earlier times as they confront contemporary religious limitations imposed on females.

"Kiss Me Not on the Eyes," by Lebanese writer-director Jocelyne Saab reveals the conflicts for women in Egyptian culture by juxtaposing female sensuality with female circumcision; love of poetry with religious repression; emancipated dance with physical restraint. Amid the lavish color, intoxicating music, and historical architecture of contemporary Cairo, Dunia, a free-spirited, belly dancer, studies Arabic love poetry at the university as she maneuvers her way through a repressive society. But once she marries her ardent long-term boyfriend Mandouh, he constricts Dunia’s independent nature. Instead she finds philosophical nourishment in her relationship with her professor. "Kiss Me Not" explores cross-cultural concerns about ownership of women’s bodies and, by extension, the inherent pleasure within them.

In August 2003, Palestinian-Australian documentary filmmaker Sherine Salama, awakened convinced that Yasser Arafat was going to die, and soon. She recognized the importance of following her prescient dream and "The Last Days of Yasser Arafat" resulted. During our interview in San Francisco, Salama told me she is not, by nature, a very political person, but she felt “a kind of duty to make a film about Arafat before he died.” In "Last Days" Salama accomplishes the daunting task of humanizing the typically demonized president. Much of the documentary’s action revolves around her attempt to break through the inner sanctum of aids, bodyguards, and press secretaries surrounding Arafat's compound at Ramallah to get an interview with him. It takes more than a year, but she finally ingratiates herself and her interview is granted. When the documentarian meets the despot their conversation is amiable and Arafat is engaged. Within a month, after Arafat’s death, Salama realizes that hers is the ultimate interview. By following her instincts she provided the world with a final glimpse of one of the most controversial leaders of the 20th century. I urge you to check out this film and the others featured in this article for an unforgettable look at women’s lives in the Middle East.

NOTE: This article was first published in the July/August 2007 issue of "Release Print."

Cathleen teaches a six-week course, Faces of Women in Middle Eastern Cinema, begining this October (2007) at UC Santa Cruz, Extension in Cupertino.


Blogger Paul Martin said...

Nice article, Cathleen. I don't feel I have much to add, but enjoyed the read. I enjoyed Panahi's Offside a lot, and his The Circle is my favourite Iranian film. I like his sense of humanity and the way he presents issues in his work. It's unfortunate that his films are unable to be screened in his homeland.

7:26 PM  
Blogger Cathleen Rountree said...

Hey, Paul ... Great to hear form you. it's been several months. i'm off to Toronto soon, so i'll be blogging regularly again. Iranian Cinema is one of my favorite. So many excellent films. Look for BORDER CAFE. This fall i'm teaching a course through the Univ. of Calif. at Santa Cruz: Faces of Women in Middle Eastern Cinema. (Actually, writing this to you reminds me to list it on my site!) We will take in a couple of features at the Arab Film Fest in San Francisco, and end with a Middle-Eastern dinner on the final night, so it should be fun. Take care, and thanks a lot for checking in! C.

6:07 PM  
Blogger Paul Martin said...

Yes, I'm a big fan of Iranian cinema. I like the ability to tell simple stories that are compelling with little resources. Offside certainly fits in this category, though The Circle was a little more complex (and darker than most, which is probably why I like it so much).

I made a point of seeing the only Iranian film screening at this year's Melbourne International Film Festival, Half Moon. If you don't know, it's a story about an elderly Kurdish musician trying to travel from Iran to Kurdish Iraq for a final concert with his sons, and the difficulties they encounter along the way. It's not among my favourite Iranian films, but is very enjoyable and shares a common aesthetic. Women's issues are a sub-theme. It's worth seeing if you get the chance.

2:55 AM  
Blogger Cathleen Rountree said...

Paul, I saw HALF MOON at Toronto last year. Have you seen any of Ghobadi's earlier films: A TIME FOR DRUNKEN HORSES, MAROONED IN IRAQ, TURTLES CAN FLY? His films are always wrenching, yet contemplative. He's developing a fine sensibility and body of work.

3:28 PM  
Blogger Paul Martin said...

I've seen none of those, Cathleen, though both A Time For Drunken Horses and Turtles Can Fly had theatrical releases here. I can't remember why I didn't get to see them, but I think they only had short releases.

7:30 PM  
Blogger Cathleen Rountree said...


Have you heard of Netflix (DVDs through the mail)? Do you guys have any service like that in Melbourne? If not, someone could make a fortune starting that service!

2:06 PM  
Blogger Paul Martin said...

I've heard of Netflix, though I'm not sure if we have it here. We do have other similar services, which don't particularly interest me. I watch very little DVD, preferring the big screen experience. I do, however, buy DVDs of films by directors who particularly interest me.

4:38 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home